Irish Drivers Could Save €300 Annually by Switching Motor Insurance Providers
New analysis from the Central Bank of Ireland indicates that consumers could reduce their annual motor insurance costs by roughly €300 by actively comparing quotes. Despite substantial price disparities among major insurers, only 9% of drivers currently switch providers when their policies renew.
Irish motorists could save approximately €300 annually on car insurance by actively shopping around for new quotes, according to fresh research from the Central Bank of Ireland. The regulator’s analysis highlights a significant gap between potential savings and consumer behavior, revealing that just 9% of drivers switch insurers when their policies come up for renewal.
The findings are drawn from an examination of online quotations for new business motor insurance obtained in June from eight major insurers. These companies collectively underwrite more than 90% of the private motor insurance market in Ireland. The study utilized 16 distinct consumer profiles to uncover substantial disparities in pricing for identical driver categories across different providers.
According to the Central Bank’s National Claims Information Database (NCID) 2025 report, the average motor insurance premium in Ireland currently stands at roughly €655. However, the regulator noted that achieving a lower quote often requires consumers to search "more widely." This is particularly true for higher-risk profiles, such as individuals with limited driving experience, those holding penalty points, or drivers who use their vehicles for business purposes, for whom online quotes are not always readily available.
The research also shed light on the methods consumers use to manage their insurance. While 53% of drivers telephone their insurer at renewal and one in five renew without any engagement, only 4% utilize price-comparison websites. A fifth of motorists use a broker, while 18% purchase directly from an insurer’s website.
Seána Cunningham, the Central Bank’s Director of Insurance, emphasized that cost is not the sole determinant for consumers. "It is not just about price," she stated. "Consumers should also compare the level and type of cover provided to make sure they are getting the right cover for them."
Geography remains a critical factor in determining premium costs. Insurers treat the Eircode, or postal code, as a crucial element in risk assessment, with premiums varying significantly based on local claims histories and risk levels across different regions.
In the latest Chill Car Insurance Pricing Index report, Dublin dropped two places to 16th overall, placing it in the lower half of the table for affordability. The average premium for drivers in the capital is €656. While this is lower than the highest costs seen in counties such as Longford, where premiums reach €785, Dublin motorists still pay considerably more than those in lower-risk areas.
Kilkenny has emerged as the most affordable county for vehicle insurance, claiming the top spot with an average premium of €584. It narrowly edged out Waterford for the position. At the opposite end of the spectrum, Longford remains the most costly county at €785, followed closely by Louth at €745 and Limerick at €710.
E.Jarallah--al-Hayat